Return to Reflections index page

From the Gowanda PennySaver News "Reflections" series compiled by Mary Pankow. issue date - March 4, 2001

Eagle Tavern - Around 1824, J. McMillain constructs the Eagle Tavern at the corner of Buffalo and Perry streets. Mr. Potter is proprietor of the establishment. In 1842, the Presbyterian Church burns and worship is held in the tavern's ballroom, also the site where school is held, both temporary situations. When every business building burns in the great fire of 1856, the Plumb block and Eagle Tavern are the only survivors. The first gas well is drilled in 1863 and used to light the tavern. An 1898 ad lists these amenities at the Gowanda House, formerly Eagle Tavern: ".. Choice wines and liquors. Best accommodations. Hot and cold water. Bath rooms. John Bader, Proprietor." More than half a century later, in 1964, the Gowanda Village Board approves a permit for Robert Bowen to "demolish the apartment building" at the comer of Buffalo and Perry streets for a 40-car parking area. The site is still a parking lot today. (Photograph courtesy of the Gowanda Historical Society.)